Jeez, Rowena, you must be super special – not just asked about a particular cover, but even what KIND of cover you want. I looked at your 3 examples, and I couldn’t decide at all. They all look good to me, even the traditional fantasy. I’m not generally mad on the traditional illustration, but your example looks good. My only contribution is that the symbolic type of cover doesn’t exactly suggest ‘rollicking’.
Cheers
Richard
You’re right, Richard. The symbolic cover, doesn’t suggest ‘Rollicking Fantasy’.